question I'll second Maybe the back Jonas' start move with to afterwards. Joc. question then and Thanks,
the according rules. we related given to just improved that we XXXX, valuation earnings So That the of that, to under tax now that can a and to the profitability benefit of for affected came valuation we it profitability subsidiary, with to against, in GAAP acquired the the tax business when accounting, where with Vale put - that allowance Brazil assets. GAAP ended the associated point historic acquisitions, that has certain is that having What's our GAAP transpired year. remove allowance now the subsidiary up
as we bit effective you again got our provided came benefits rate down When and up through tax statement reported run that we income through lot earnings through tax the as the the and eminent, mix became they the these of to quite were that tax year, the be that finished opinions look we work, our quarter which foreign all and our tax and those it for would foreign P&L tax recorded. actually be take that's in going And tax our tax that on it that's on fourth the were our and needing recognize apparent some realized Now a but where when originally we rate ended a - came the on we that our last year, sheet. we our to But brought year, had as temporary level volatility line, analysis, again, permanent. need to to benefits to concluded the line. case, around benefits nature in for Jonas' at balance thought question be concluded in we out we effective earnings of to, our going out the foreign expected, what work rate that
keep mind. couple in As we things into of go forward XXXX, to a
recognized tax in foreign continue XXXX, our years. the rate we benefit in benefits expect that future to First, to we that
The States, in the phosphate is in other thing is income our our lowest more which United that the is jurisdiction. better generated does, business mind to keep the tax
So the better lower rate should that go. our business performs, the